A Nanny’s Manifesto, or Things You Should Know About Me Before You Leave Me Alone With Your Kids
(I am thinking of giving this to my current employers, but am worried that it seems a little harsh (see final bullet point below). What do you think? I’ve been working with the family for about a month already, so they already have some sense of who I am and what I believe in.)
- I am interested in acting as a facilitator of self-sufficiency. I am not interested in waiting on people. If I am doing my job well, it might look as though I’m not doing much at all. I believe that your children are capable of cleaning up after themselves, making their own toast, packing their own backpacks, pouring their own cereal, and rinsing their own dishes. I do not choose to do those things for them, but to help them learn how to do it for themselves.
- I believe in having clear boundaries and consistently enforcing them. Your kids will not be confused about what I expect from them.
- I believe in allowing kids to learn by experiencing the (safe) natural consequences of their actions. If they choose to wear sweatpants to the beach, then they will have to deal with having wet clingy pants. This will not hurt them. I will stop them from doing things that damage themselves or others or the environment. I recognize that my role is somewhat different than yours in this area.
- My role is different than yours. No doubt, this is self-evident. But I want to say it because there will no doubt be times that you are frustrated that I made a different decision than you would have. I am not a parent. Ideally, I would be a sort of respected (but still groovy) auntie. If there are boundaries that are very important to you (like which clothes kids are allowed to wear to the beach), you will need to be sure that those are communicated to me clearly.
- I do not see it as my role to keep your kids comfortable at all times. In fact, they will almost certainly be uncomfortably wet, muddy, tired, or bored at times. They will also almost certainly be joyously wet and muddy and too tired to even tell you about all the adventures we had today. You can’t have one without the other. I intend to push their boundaries because that is how people grow. Growth is often uncomfortable.
- Speaking of mud. Your kids will get muddy. You should be prepared for this. I bring an extra change of clothes with me to work every day. Your kids should have clothes that it is okay to get muddy, and they should be responsible for knowing which clothes those are. We will even spend a lot of time outside in the winter, even in the rain, so they should have warm clothes that it’s okay to get muddy. I will take responsibility for helping your kids clean those clothes properly so that you don’t have to deal with muddy clothes in the house.
- I like computer games, and I come from a generation that spends far more time on the internet than a lot of folks would consider healthy. In my previous life as a web designer, I spent 8 hours a day online and then came home and spent another 4 or 5 hours online during my personal time, mostly doing such “unproductive” things as learning how to build community via online games and how to engage in friendships via online bulletin boards. Therefore, I am unlikely to be as concerned as you are that your children spend hours online doing “unproductive” things. If you have a specific time limit that you would like me to enforce, I am glad to do so.
- I believe in encouraging kids to think for themselves. This often has unexpected results, which you should be prepared for. Once kids start thinking for themselves, they often start questioning the reasoning of the people who used to do their thinking for them. In most cases, that is you. Your kids will do this anyway, whether someone encourages it or not. I intend to teach your kids reasonable and respectful ways to question authority, but be aware that I believe in questioning authority.
- I believe in honoring kids’ need to relax. Don’t expect me to have your kids actively engaged at all times. Just like grown-ups, kids need space to just zone out and not make decisions or engage with other people. Particularly during the school year, no part of their day is designed to just give them some space with no expectations. As someone who has really high space requirements, I see this as something really important that I can give to your kids.
- I also believe in honoring kids’ natural curiosity and desire to explore. Expect that I will figure out what excites your kids and that I will encourage them to (safely) pursue those things. Excited about fire? Let’s learn how to make fire by rubbing sticks together (and let’s also talk about fire safety and responsibility to one’s community while we’re at it). Excited about berries? Let’s see how many different kinds of edible berries we can find (and talk a little about ecology and thankfulness while we’re at it).
- Know that I am not a naturally outgoing and charismatic person. It will take me a while to get to know your kids, and it will take them a while to realize that I do, after all, have a sense of humor. For that matter, it will probably take you and I a while to figure out how we relate to each other.
- I love working with kids. I am excited to get to know your kids in particular. I look forward to learning a lot from your family. Creating relationships is a slow process for me, but it is a rewarding process. I hope that my relationship with your kids will be rewarding for everyone involved.
- I am a blunt (some would say tactless) person. If you want me to know something, I won’t get it if you try to be subtle. I take feedback and criticism well, so please just say it like it is. I will try to provide feedback to you in the manner that you would like to hear it, but be aware that I am not good at tact and subtlety. If I say something that seems harsh, please try to hear it as coming from a place of good intentions. If you don’t understand where I’m coming from, please say so.
September 1st, 2007 at 9:57 am
I don’t think it sounds harsh. Perhaps someone who either doesn’t know you, or is easily offended (by reading stuff between the lines that may or may not be there) might think it is. You can be a nanny for my kids anytime.
–Kathy
September 1st, 2007 at 8:12 pm
I don’t think it sounds harsh either. I think it would be well received if presented along with “if anything on here is an issue for you, please discuss it with me”.
It sounds a lot like what the Boston Teacher Residency program is looking for in new teachers–if you ever decide to apply to join a liberal teacher education program, submit this!
I could use some enabling to get my dishes and laundry done…
September 2nd, 2007 at 12:41 pm
It doesn’t sound harsh to *me* either, but I know you and you inherited much of your style from me. So, I wouldn’t be as likely to see it as harsh. I am 98% certain, however, that most people (esp parents of the little darlings in question) will take it as an affront. Don’t give it to them unless you feel confident that you have an open secure communication and/or they communicate much the same way you do. That’s just my opinion. Personally, I would rewrite it, endeavoring to make exactly the same points with a bit less intensity.
September 4th, 2007 at 6:49 pm
Hi Deanna - I only wish I could have had a nanny or been a mother with the wisdom of your writing. Tough to know how your employers will take it but I’m sure you will make the right decision.
jane
September 5th, 2007 at 1:20 pm
Hi Deanna! Great post! I love: “I believe in having clear boundaries and consistently enforcing them. Your kids will not be confused about what I expect from them.” Your kids will not be confused .. that cracks me up. I like it.
The only thing as a parent of two that stands out as a flag is the following: “I intend to push their boundaries because that is how people grow. Growth is often uncomfortable.”
I love to push my own boundaries, and I love to push others with whom I have received permission to do so. However, at the outset (if you were applying to be a nanny or had just begun being a nanny for my kids) I would be a bit frightened if I read that line and you had not gotten permission from me and the kids yet. Pushing boundaries and focusing on the uncomfortability is something that does not sit well with the parent in me.
Not that I don’t want my kids boundaries to be pushed … I love that. BUT, anyone who is doing the pushing needs to first get connected to my kids in a “Oh my gosh, you are the most incredible being in the Universe and I LOVE you” kind of way. Only after that kind of connection am I interested in hearing how they are going to be pushing boundaries.
Peace,
Rees
September 6th, 2007 at 9:51 pm
Hey. I commented and now it is not here. Humpf. Anyway, I LOVE this post, and I agree somewhat with Mom about needing to sugar a little for others to hear our message. It’s just unfortunate because being direct is such a clear way to communicate and yet it makes people too uncomfortable to process it.
September 7th, 2007 at 1:08 pm
Thanks so much for your comments everyone. Rees, I think you have hit on something important that I hadn’t known how to express. This “manifesto” itself is a lot of boundary-pushing and not a lot of “I think you all are wonderful people”. I’m changing the item you pointed out to read like this:
I do not see it as my role to keep your kids comfortable at all times. In fact, they will almost certainly be uncomfortably wet, muddy, tired, or bored at times. They will also almost certainly be joyously wet and muddy and too tired to even tell you about all the adventures we had today. Your children’s physical and emotional safety is really important to me. Safety and comfort are not the same thing, but I recognize that they are intertwined. I will pay attention when your kids tell me, verbally or otherwise, that they need something.
I’m going to try going over it with the parents with just that one change. I’ll let you know how it goes. For the most part, these are all things that they’ve agreed to here and there in separate conversations, so it won’t be coming out of the blue. We are planning a meeting specifically for talking about expectations and intentions, and also to sign the official employment contract. I intend to read it to them, with a lead-in about how this isn’t directed at them specifically, it’s just things that I’ve thought of that would be important to me in working with any family, and that they are mostly already on board with these things. This is more just a way for me to clarify my thoughts and make sure we’re on the same page.
September 12th, 2007 at 6:53 pm
We’ll be interested to hear how it goes, DeAnna.
October 4th, 2007 at 12:56 pm
[…] Also, lest some of you worry (hi Mom!) I am also looking for a job. Basically, the last job boiled down to a major misunderstanding where when I said, “I would like to be a wilderness mentor and I’ve never worked with anyone disabled before” they heard me say, “I would like to be a companion for your developmentally disabled daughter and would like nothing better than to sit around and watch movies with her”. I never gave them my Nanny’s Manifesto because shortly after I wrote it, it became clear that it wasn’t relevant to them. They were not looking for a nanny, they were looking to buy a friend for their daughter, a role I might have been willing to play had they let me know that’s what they wanted. So whatever. Let me know if you know of any ways to make money while sitting around listening to knitting podcasts and designing curtains. Filed under: home, work, I am the center of my universe, fiber stuff — deandail @ 12:51 pm […]